INDEX

Topics are arranged alphabetically in the INDEX.
Showing posts with label ancient wisdom. Show all posts
Showing posts with label ancient wisdom. Show all posts

Saturday, April 11, 2020

Wisdom is Expressed in the Practical




Alice C. Linsley

It is said that Philosophy is the pursuit of wisdom. I taught Philosophy for 14 years I doubt that my students took the courses because they were motivated to pursue wisdom.

Wisdom is not valued in our time because it is perceived as impractical. Fortunately, some educators and employers have begun to see Philosophy's value in the sharpening of the intellect.

Aristotle recognized that wisdom is born of experience. In Nicomachean Ethics he wrote:

While young men do indeed become good geometers and mathematicians and attain theoretical wisdom in such matters, they do not attain practical wisdom. The reason is that practical wisdom is concerned with particulars as well as with universals, and knowledge of particulars comes from experience.

Therefore we ought to pay as much attention to the sayings and opinions, undemonstrated though they are, of wise and experienced older men as we do to demonstrated truths. For experience has  given such men an eye with which they can see correctly. 


For the ancients, wisdom was not intellectual, but practical. It meant reading the stars to predict seasonal changes that affect agriculture. It involved understanding tensile strengths of metals and different rocks. Wisdom built the pyramids using geometry. Wisdom excavated mines. Wisdom enlarged herds through animal husbandry. Wisdom conquered the Nile and the seas through the development of sailing. Wisdom pioneered medicine.

The rabbis taught that study of the Torah leads to Wisdom. However, wisdom came before Torah. It was gained through observation and experimentation. The ancients were motivated to gain wisdom in order to solve problems and make improvements in their lives.

In the ancient world, philosophy found expression in science and technology. Before the academies of Greece, there were mines to be excavated and ships to be built. Before Plato, there were priests keeping records of remedies for thousands of ailments and diseases.

Philosophy has value. The value is not in ego aggrandizement through winning an argument. The value is expressed in the practical ways wisdom serves humanity.

Monday, April 4, 2016

Ancient Philosophers Portrayed on Byzantine Frescoes


Fresco of Hippocrates dates to 1342
National Library of France

John Sanidopoulos has posted images of ancient Byzantine frescoes that pay homage to Thales, Hippocrates, Plato, Aristotle and Sophocles, among other wise ones.  This is well worth a look.  Go here.

Related reading: Ancient Seats of Wisdom; Who Laid the Foundations of Science?; Wisdom Seeks to Understand; Paul's Application of Greek Philosophy; Plato's Debt to Ancient Egypt

Friday, March 28, 2014

Assessing the Historical Reliability of Ancient Sources


Alice C. Linsley

I teach my students to evaluate the reliability and appropriateness of their sources. Is the source recognized widely? Does the time period pertain to the focus of the research being done? For whom was the source written? What is the purpose of the work, or the writer's intention?

When it comes to information about the archaic world (c.10,000-2000 BC) and the ancient world (c.2000-500 BC) students are faced with a great challenge because there are not many "primary" sources that they can read in their own languages. Generally, students will find these sources helpful:

    Herodotus's Histories
    The Old Testament
    Pliney's History
    Flavius Josephus's The Antiquities of the Jews
    Julius Caesar's Gallic Wars

Here are my thoughts, as one who is especially interested in the ethics and religious practices of archaic communities.

Herodotus's Histories contains much that is factual, but he was concerned mostly about his own Roman people so the scope is sometimes too limited. The same can be said for Josephus's The Antiquities of the Jews.

Pliney's Natural History is too recent to be of value for study of the archaic world (4000-2000 BC). It is a great encyclopedic work covering botany, agriculture, zoology and minerals, but it makes statements about Africa that are wrong. It dates to around 75-77 AD.

Caesar's Gallic Wars is a classic example of Roman propaganda and hero worship. Julius Caesar's wars were to promote himself by expansion of the Roman Empire into France and Belgium. It dates to about 54 BC and focuses on his successful military campaigns.

Of these writings, the Old Testament books of Genesis, Exodus, Job, and Ruth provide the widest focus and actually contain data about the ancient world (2000-500 BC). Much of the data mined from these books has been confirmed by archaeology, linguistics, DNA studies and biblical anthropology. Anthropological information mined from Genesis has enable scholars to reconstruction the movement of Nilo-Saharans and Saharo-Nubian populations into Arabia, Syria, Southern Europe, the Indus Valley, and Southern China. There is also much information about the religious practices of these dispersed populations that reflect their ethics and worldview. Biblical anthropology has also identified The Social Structure of the Biblical Hebrew.

Related reading:  Ethical Concerns of Archaic Communities; Seats of WisdomEthics of Archaic Communities; Themistoclea of DelphiAncient Wisdom, Science, and Technology; Religion of the Archaic Rulers; The High Places

Saturday, February 8, 2014

Themistoclea of Delphi


Alice C. Linsley

Themistoclea was a 6th century seer or Pythia of Apollo at the temple at Delphi. In Greek, themis refers to divine order or natural law. She is reputed to have been the teacher of Pythagoras, the great mathematician of Samos who believed that the workings of the material world could be expressed in terms of numbers.

In Diogenes Laeterius’ work, The Lives and Opinions of Eminent Philosophers, in the section concerning the "Life Of Pythagoras," Diogenes states that "Aristoxenus asserts that Pythagoras derived the greater part of his ethical doctrines from Themistoclea, the priestess at Delphi."

Temple at Delphi


Themistoclea represents an ancient epistemological approach which wedded experience, reason and the supernatural. As the Prophetess of Apollo at Delphi she would have been a source of much ancient wisdom, including knowledge of the natural world, astronomy, medicine, music, mathematics, animal husbandry and philosophy. She would have offered advice pertaining to sowing and harvests, whether to go to war, and who and when to marry.

Women such as Themistoclea were often deified, either posthumously or during their lifetimes. She is called "Pythia" and the python is an ancient symbol for immortality. Even today python fat is used in Africa in healing rituals. It is believed to have restorative properties. The Mofu holy man of Cameroon mixes python fat with the blood of a sacrificed animal and uses the mixture with stones in a ritual to restore rain to the earth.

The Hebrew (habiru) holy ones were likewise regarded as deities (elohiym). The plural form for God in Arabic and Hausa is Allohi, the equivalent of the Hebrew Elohiym. El and Al are very ancient names for God. The plural form appears in Genesis 1: In the beginning elohiym created the heavens and the earth. The word also appears in Genesis 6:2, which speaks of the "sons of the elohiym" who took wives from the daughters of men. The plural form relates to the ancient Horites from whom we receive this material. They are the origin of Israel's priesthood and why Jews call their ancestors "horim."

The Horite ruler-priests were regarded as deified "sons" of God. They served as the wise ones or the ruler's holy counselors. As such, they are called gods, as in Exodus 22:28: "Thou shalt not revile the gods (elohiym), nor curse the ruler of thy people."

Monday, January 20, 2014

Ancient Wisdom, Science and Technology


Alice C. Linsley

In a recent (2014) conversation with self-proclaimed atheists, I was told that theology and religion emerged because people who lived before the time of science needed to explain natural phenomena; the implication being that we no longer need religion now that we have science. I attempted to explain that the earliest developments in science and technology were motivated by religious concerns, but they were not interested. Their minds were closed and reasoning with them proved a waste of time.

As the Romanian sociologist Mircea Eliade has shown, people of antiquity believed that things on earth are patterned after things in the heavens. Eliade called these “celestial archetypes.” The notion “as in the heavens, so on earth” is common among tribal peoples. Their rituals and ceremonies mirror the celestial patterns which they observe in the clock-like motion of the fixed stars and constellations. Among archaic peoples, these observations were done by a caste of ruler-priests who served at advisers to the early kingdom builders.

It was a risky business because there were serious consequences if their calculations were wrong. If the ceremony was not performed on exactly the right day, the advisers could be blamed for violating a celestial pattern. If war broke out, or the crops failed, or there was a flood, the ruler’s advisers were blamed. This happened to Chinese astronomers who failed to predict the solar eclipse of 2134 BC. The emperor ordered that they all be executed.

The threat of punishment, even death, motivated the king’s advisers to be as accurate as possible in their calculations. This led to the development of sidereal astronomy. The sidereal day (four minutes longer than the solar day) is the time required for the earth’s rotation to be synchronized with fixed stars. Solar time is the measurement of time according to the earth’s rotation around the sun, but sidereal time is the measurement relative to a distant star. It is used in astronomy to predict when a star will be overhead.

When making ethical decisions, especially decisions that pertained to the timing of important events such as royal weddings and the signing of treaties, ancient peoples relied on observations of the stars and constellations which move in a fixed pattern. Sidereal astronomy is based on the actual location of stars and constellations, unlike popular astrology which is based on culturally relative symbolism associated with stars and constellations. Sidereal astronomy developed out of an ethical concern to uphold the celestial pattern believed to have been established by the Creator in the beginning.

This worldview is alien to modern Americans and regarded as superstition by atheists. Yet the acute observation of ancient peoples gave birth to technologies such as metal and stonework and to the development of sciences such as horticulture, animal husbandry, sidereal astronomy, and medicine.

Let us consider but a few examples.

Horticulture
The ancestors of the Nes craftsmen of Anatolian sites like Gobleki Tepe cultivated both einkorn and emmer wheats about 12,000 years ago, according to genetics and archaeological studies. African rice was domesticated from the wild ancestor Oryza barthii (Oryza brevilugata) by peoples living in the Benue-Niger floodplain about 3,000 years ago. Rice grain formed the basis of weight measurement from East Africa to Sulawesi. In Madagascar, the weight of one grain of rice is called vary which corresponds to the Swahili wari and to the Dravidian verasu. The common stem of these words indicates that these people kept written records of commercial weights.

The ancients observed that the seeds of plants that fall to the ground produce plants of the same kind. It was logical to assume that the seed that should fall to the earth is the seed of plants, which spring forth from the earth. Likewise, the seed of man should fall on his own type (the womb), from which man comes forth. This was regarded as the divine order in creation. Therefore, the ancients regarded both onanism (spilling of human semen) and homosex to be in violation of the established order. This is the ancient wisdom that based moral law on observed patterns in nature.

Animal Husbandry
Cattle were domesticated in what is today Kenya 15,000 years ago. The common term for cattle or cow in the many African languages is nag (Wolog, Fulani), nagge (Hausa), ning (Angas, Ankwe) and ninge (Susu). This corresponds to the Egyptian word ng or nag.

Red and black Nubian cattle herders

Cattle bones were found in graves of the elite classes at Hierakonpolis (Nekhen in Sudan) and cow skulls were used to mark the pan graves of the ancient Saharans. The oldest evidence of domestication of wild pigs is found at Nekhen, Maadi, Abydos, and Armant, near graves belonging to the poorer classes, indicating that the diet of the lower classes included pork. Cows were also domesticated by the Nilo-Saharans, who even took them on their boats (see second image below). 


Boats and cows of the ancient Nilo-Saharans

Sidereal Astronomy
Sidereal astronomy is real science based on observation of the arrangement and movement of the fixed stars and planets. This science originated among Abraham's Nilo-Saharan ancestors who had recorded information about the fixed stars and clock-like motion of the planets and constellations for thousands of years. By 4245 BC, the priests of the Upper Nile had established a calendar based on the appearance of the star Sirius that becomes visible to the naked eye once every 1,461 years. Apparently, they had been tracking this star and connecting it to seasonal changes and agriculture for thousands of years. The priest Manetho reported in his history (241 BC) that Nilotic Africans had been “star-gazing” as early as 40,000 years ago. They shared this knowledge with the kings of Egypt.

The ancient Egyptians shared the knowledge with the ancient Greeks. Plato claimed that the Africans had been tracking the heavens for 10,000 years. Plato studied with an Egyptian priest for 13 years and knew about Earth's Great Year, also called the "Platonic Year." This is the time of between 25,000 and 28,000 years that it takes for Earth to complete the cycle of axial precession. This precession was known to Plato who defined the "perfect year" as the return of the celestial bodies (planets) and the diurnal rotation of the fixed stars to their original positions.

The ancients were motivated to understand the celestial pattern because they believed that the order in creation was fixed by the Creator, and they were concerned about trespassing boundaries or violating the order in creation. 

Medicine
The Edwin Smith papyrus is the world's oldest known surgical document (c. 1600 BC). It is written in the hieratic script of ancient Egypt and Kush and reveals a high level of sophistication in medical care. It gives detailed descriptions of anatomy, diagnosis, treatment, and prognosis of forty-eight types of medical problems. It describes closing wounds with sutures, preventing and curing infection with honey and moldy bread (both known to contain antibiotics), application of raw meat to stop bleeding, and treatment of head and spinal cord injuries. The Nubians also used antibiotics. Between 350 and 550 AD Nubians laced their beer with tetracycline.

Other Achievements

The great prehistoric monoliths and circles of standing stones attest to the skill of the early architects and stone masons.

The rich burial goods discovered with the early chiefs and rulers attest to the skill of metal workers. Consider the amazing hoard buried with Varna Man 7,000 years ago.